So we all know Homestuck gets a lot of...fans. Both good and bad. I figured I was going to throw this topic up for a little fun. Have a fan troll that you've seen that really, really sucks? Post it here!
Example~.
This is one of my new characters, Audrey The Demon Troll.
Birthday: Nov 11
Age: 13
Zodiac: Scorpio
Favorites: Internet, her Electric Guitar, Music, and hanging out with the gang.
Hates: ......pretty much....sometimes.......EVERYTHING!
Hobbies: Going onto the Internet, Playing her Electric Guitar, and Hanging out (sometimes)
Friends: Lynni (CapricornSniper) and other characters!
Gender: Female
Type of Person: Human/Troll/Demon
(And pretty much can't think of anything else to say.......for now.) -_-;
And added! I argued with her! :D
*TheTwilightOwl 7 hours ago Hobbyist Writer
I'm not sure if the in general idea is...quite possible to produce a character such as this.
~TaurusGirl911 52 minutes ago
...what the heck are you saying??? T_l*TheTwilightOwl 31 minutes ago Hobbyist Writer
What I'm saying that, since you seem to fancy Gamzee, your Oc would have to screw over the entire time line of Homestuck to make this work. Meaning that a troll would have to fall in love with a human and produce a child way before the timeline of Homestuck even began. Thus, the character immediately breaks canon in the first place simply by existing.
There's also the issue of not knowing if humans and trolls can produce a child in the first place. And the 'demon' thing is so far-fetched, it makes me face palm.
~TaurusGirl911 20 minutes ago
... T_T
OK, the story is that her parents were trolls, and she was an original troll back then before she met the demon, which who appeared and went inside of her head and stayed there for the rest of her life until she dies, after her parents left her...
She is in love with a clone named Dark Tobio, which who belongs to a person on DA named CapricornSniper (Lynni-Kun), and they had a life together later on throughout her years..... T_T
GET IT NOW!!! X(*TheTwilightOwl 17 minutes ago Hobbyist Writer
...None of it makes sense time line wise or not. Demon's done exist in Homestuck. They're not there so introducing an aspect of demons doesn't work because it immediately screws the original story line over.
Making an Oc means you have to work the character into the plot, which, you have not done. You've just created a Mary-Sue of a fail troll.
~TaurusGirl911 16 minutes ago
...... T_T*TheTwilightOwl 13 minutes ago Hobbyist Writer
Yes, you're gonna get people who call you out on your fan trolls. Because this is a big fandom and I write a lot. So take the advice, straighten out your character, and make something that would make sense to the fandom.
~TaurusGirl911 6 minutes ago
... T_T
Ok, you know what, SCREW YOU!
Cause some other homestuck fans on DA have seen my Demon Troll character, and they didn't make a big deal about it, like how your doing it right NOW! Just because you write alot, and your 22, doesn't mean you can judge every single thing about my character, so BUG OFF! From now on, I am going to block you, and ignore whatever you are going to say about my character, cause I don't give a FUCK ABOUT IT, OR YOU!!! X(
And then she blocked me. :D As usual with butt hurt kids~.